Piers Riley-Smith, acting for St Helens Council, has successfully resisted an appeal against an Enforcement Notice issued against a ‘telegraph pole boundary wall’ erected in St Helens.
The Council had sought to enforce against a wall constructed entirely from old telegraph poles erected around a wedding venue in St Helens without planning permission.
The Appellant argued that the Notice was invalid because it did not clearly identify the breach of planning control. The Appellant claimed that they had interpreted the Notice to mean that each individual pole was a separate building operation instead of the poles together forming a wall. On that basis, the Appellant argued that a number of individual poles had been erected over 4 years ago and so was immune from enforcement.
Under cross-examination, the Appellant accepted that he had initially understood (correctly) that the Notice related to the whole wall but had then decided to run the ‘theoretical’ argument at Appeal following discussion with his planning consultant.
The Council submitted that the Appellant’s argument was flawed legally and logically as not only had the Appellant properly understood the Notice at first, but it was wrong to salami slice a ‘building’ into its component parts for circumventing planning controls.
The Inspector upheld the notice, dismissed the appeal and awarded the Council their full costs.
The main decision can be found here, and the costs decision here.
Piers Riley-Smith was instructed by Mark Fisher of St Helens Council.
Download the Appeal Decision here.
Download the Costs Decision here.
36 Young Street, Manchester, M3 3FT DX: 718188 MCH 3 Direct Dial: 0161 832 9082
5 Park Square, Leeds, LS1 2NE DX: 713113 LEEDS PARK SQ Direct Dial: 0113 242 1123
Embassy House, 60 Church Street, Birmingham, B3 2DJ DX: 13023 BIRMINGHAM Direct Dial: 0121 200 3570
We are pleased to announce that Andrew Hogan and Gordon Exall (@CivilLitTweet) will be speaking at the… https://t.co/o2p7nbSHJl Kings Chambers 6 days, 22 hours ago..
Our Women In Costs: Development Brunch and Seminar is now underway! It is fantastic to see so many women from the… https://t.co/wrXH3qSXcG Kings Chambers 1 week ago..
Wilson Horne successful in High Court claim in relation to a conditional sale agreement and the refusal to validate… https://t.co/WLN8S1GjIk Kings Chambers 1 week ago..
We are delighted to announce that Rosie Kight has been appointed as a fee paid Judge of the Employment Tribunals (E… https://t.co/5J2MJlUlrM Kings Chambers 1 week, 1 day ago..
Andrew Hogan successful again in another QOCS appeal in the Court of Appeal. Find out more:… https://t.co/DmfV3hPwCR Kings Chambers 1 week, 2 days ago..
© Copyright 2023 Kings Chambers. All rights reserved.