Kings Chambers has successfully acted in a very major planning inquiry relating to unauthorised development at Thornton Science Park in Ellesmere Port. For many years, the site had been known as the Thornton Research Centre, operated by Shell as an international research and development location. After an unsuccessful attempt to operate it as a business park, Shell sold the site to the University of Chester in 2014. Since then, it has been operated as a Science Park and as the University’s Faculty of Science and Engineering, with about 400 undergraduate and postgraduate students studying at the site. There are also over 40 commercial tenants working in the science sector, present on the site.
After acquiring the site and having already started to operate the Faculty, the University sought retrospective planning permission for a material change of use for the Faculty buildings on site. The Science Park is within the Inner Zone of Stanlow Oil Refinery, an Upper Tier COMAH site, and the second biggest refinery in the UK. The Health and Safety Executive provided a strongly worded consultation response, advising against the grant of permission on public safety grounds. The Council accepted the advice and the application was refused.
The University also later sought confirmation that their use of the site was lawful, through making an application for a Lawful Development Certificate, arguing that the introduction of the faculty was not a material change of use of the site. The Council certified that the lawful use was, broadly, the R&D use, and refused to include education and workplace training.
The Council also took enforcement action in respect of the breach of planning control.
The University appealed in respect of the enforcement action, the refusal of planning permission and the partial refusal of the certificate. An inquiry was held between November 2019 and January 2020. Martin Carter acted for the local planning authority and Giles Cannock QC (Instructed by Peter Nesbit of Eversheds-Sutherland) acted for Essar, the operator of the refinery. The HSE were also present, represented by Leading Counsel.
The Inspector's decisions were issued on 12th March 2020. In a lengthy and complex decision letter, the University’s appeals were rejected. The Inspector found that there had been a material change of use when the Faculty commenced operations as part of the mixed use on site and that the proposal was unacceptable because of the conflict with the Development Plan and also as a result of the major hazards facing the students by reason of their proximity to Stanlow. The University was given one year to remove the faculty use from the site.
The Inspector concluded that the University had behaved unreasonably as regards certain aspects of its case, and made partial awards of costs in favour of the local planning authority and the HSE.
Copies of the decision letter and costs decisions can be found below.
Costs Decision CWCC UoC
Costs Decision HSE UoC
36 Young Street, Manchester, M3 3FT
DX: 718188 MCH 3
Direct Dial: 0161 832 9082
5 Park Square, Leeds, LS1 2NE
DX: 713113 LEEDS PARK SQ
Direct Dial: 0113 242 1123
Embassy House, 60 Church Street,
Birmingham, B3 2DJ
DX: 13023 BIRMINGHAM
Direct Dial: 0121 200 3570
Sam Karim KC will join an excellent panel for a live (Zoom) debate organised by Northern Administrative Law Associa… https://t.co/qJh2BIEEAu Kings Chambers 6 days, 17 hours ago..
Kings Chambers wins Regional Set of the Year at #ChambersUKBarAwards 2022!
Find out more: https://t.co/kPrjHwEMQi… https://t.co/N0wiXFhy6h Kings Chambers 2 weeks, 2 days ago..
Join Oliver McEntee for the next in our series of webinars aimed at young legal professionals: ' Top tips for case… https://t.co/39de4dDBlP Kings Chambers 2 weeks, 3 days ago..
Piers Riley-Smith succeeds in the High Court in relation to noise nuisance and hypersensitivity under the Environme… https://t.co/nClgVbcnoe Kings Chambers 2 weeks, 5 days ago..
#WeDoProBono via @WeAreAdvocate
To celebrate #ProBonoWeek we are encouraging others to do the same!
We are prou… https://t.co/IV5HpqZF3t Kings Chambers 3 weeks, 2 days ago..
© Copyright 2022 Kings Chambers. All rights reserved.