Jonathan Wright, representing the defendant local authority in the case of Morris Homes Ltd & Ors v Cheshire West and Chester Council, has obtained the dismissal of a claim brought by a consortium of developers. The High Court delivered its judgment at the conclusion of trial on 17 October 2019.
The claim related to a major housing development in Cheshire. The developers and the local authority had entered into a planning obligation pursuant to s.106 Town and Country Planning Act 1990. The planning obligation included an overage mechanism, requiring the developers to pay a portion of their profits to the local authority. The developers contended that certain profits should be left out of the calculation (namely, revenue from ground rents and from selling freehold reversions, as well as the capitalised value of retained freehold reversions). The dispute centred on the interpretation of a specific provision in the s.106 agreement.
The parties had previously submitted their dispute to an adjudication by an independent expert, who had found in favour of the local authority on this issue. The developers later commenced a claim in the High Court, seeking a declaration that the expert’s decision was not binding, and that it was wrong in law.
Jonathan represented the defendant local authority throughout the High Court proceedings, securing a successful dismissal of the developers’ claim at trial, together with an award of costs. In delivering his judgment, His Honour Judge Pearce (sitting as Judge of the High Court) accepted the local authority’s case on contractual interpretation, and found that the disputed sums should be included in the overage calculation.
36 Young Street, Manchester, M3 3FT DX: 718188 MCH 3 Direct Dial: 0161 832 9082
5 Park Square, Leeds, LS1 2NE DX: 713113 LEEDS PARK SQ Direct Dial: 0113 242 1123
Embassy House, 60 Church Street, Birmingham, B3 2DJ DX: 13023 BIRMINGHAM Direct Dial: 0121 200 3570
In support of #InternationalWomensDay 2023, we are delighted to sponsor the @cbituk She's Shining Fundraising Lunch… https://t.co/6XAo0UqnvM Kings Chambers 2 days ago..
WEBINAR - 4.30pm 22nd February 2023 Employment Law Series: Update on Government Consultation on Statutory Code of… https://t.co/kThYMlwSn3 Kings Chambers 6 days, 21 hours ago..
We are pleased to announce that Andrew Hogan and Gordon Exall (@CivilLitTweet) will be speaking at the… https://t.co/o2p7nbSHJl Kings Chambers 2 weeks, 5 days ago..
Our Women In Costs: Development Brunch and Seminar is now underway! It is fantastic to see so many women from the… https://t.co/wrXH3qSXcG Kings Chambers 2 weeks, 5 days ago..
Wilson Horne successful in High Court claim in relation to a conditional sale agreement and the refusal to validate… https://t.co/WLN8S1GjIk Kings Chambers 2 weeks, 6 days ago..
© Copyright 2023 Kings Chambers. All rights reserved.