36 Young Street, Manchester, M3 3FT
DX: 718188 MCH 3
Direct Dial: 0161 832 9082
5 Park Square, Leeds, LS1 2NE
DX: 713113 LEEDS PARK SQ
Direct Dial: 0113 242 1123
Embassy House, 60 Church Street,
Birmingham, B3 2DJ
DX: 13023 BIRMINGHAM
Direct Dial: 0121 200 3570
Clerked by:William Brown
“ An excellent advocate with good interpersonal skills”
Specialist practitioner in planning and environmental law in which Gary is an experienced advocate and adviser. Gary is experienced in bringing and defending challenges to planning and environmental decisions in the Planning Court. Instructions in 2016 and 2017 include resisting procedural, environmental and policy challenges to the grant of planning permission to a Rugby Club, drafting grounds of resistance in a Statutory Challenge on the LPA’s understanding of affordable housing policy and the bringing of a challenge to the decision of the Secretary of State disagreeing with an Inspectors report on a major urban extension. Gary provides legal support to Plan Making Authorities including at EiP.
Gary has been instructed in a number of cases in the Planning Court, including successfully resisting a challenge by way of judicial review of the Lichfield Local Plan.
Gary deals with housing, retail, waste, highways, heritage and the full range of environmental issues at Public Inquiry.
Gary has presented papers to specialist training events held by RTPI, NAPE, ACSeS, LLG and others and is a qualified Civil and Commercial Mediator.
Gary has a wide level of experience of government work from work on the AG’s Regional Panel and has experience of highways, land, environmental, enforcement, contractual and regulatory matters associated with planning and environmental law.
Year of Call: 1985
Areas of Expertise
Advising and appearing for and against Authorities involved in the promotion of highways and transportation projects. Promoted highways orders for the Secretary of State in 2003 and 2005, advised a County Authority in 2010 respect of objections to high speed rail links to Heathrow and in 2015 advised and appeared for Manchester United in respect of their representations to the Manchester Metro extension inquiry.
2018: Leading objection against Orders promoting Mixed Use Compulsory Purchase Order ( including Student Housing ) in Middlesborough Town Centre.
2016: Objection to the confirmation of a CPO under planning powers in respect of a leisure building at Seaton Carew seafront adjoining conservation area.
2015: Advising Manchester United Limited in respect of representations to the Manchester Metro extension Inquiry.
2011: Advising Highways Agency on various development proposals in South West and have an impact on trunk road network, including at North West Quadrant Plymouth and Swindon Gateway. Appearing at Inquiry.
2010: Advising Surrey County Council in respect of “Airtrack “ proposals to extend high speed rail commuter services to Heathrow.
Advising upon and dealing with development proposals within a wide range of environmentally sensitive designations including AONB, SACs, Ramsar sites and conservation areas, including cases involving issues of sensitive design.
Enforcement appeals and environmental prosecutions, including in 2015 a prosecution of a noise abatement notice in respect of a clay pigeon shoot.
2017: Resisting proposals at a planning appeal into proposals for a new Care Village on the site of a disused Poultry Farm in Wychavon, opposed on grounds which included the impact of major development in the AONB.
2016: Planning appeal at Public Inquiry in Stratford for housing in rural village raising impact on county level grassland habitat and the evaluation of mitigation proposals.
2015: Great Heck: advising local planning authorities on nationally publicised environmental concerns and enforcement issues arising from storage and management of waste at site in Yorkshire.
2015: Prosecuting a noise abatement notice breach in respect of clay pigeon shooting before the Lay Bench.
2014: Appeal inquiry for Magna Business Park (Poole) raising issues of nightjar habitat within SPA SAC and Ramsar and employment policy ( for LPA ).
2013: Enforcement appeal inquiry concerned with conversion works of barge hull to large houseboat on the foreshore of SSSI ,SAC and Ramsar at Hayling Island (Havant) (for LPA ).
R ( on the application of Gazelle Properties Ltd ) v BANES  EWHC 3127 (Admin).
Gary has expertise in Section 78, Call In and other Inquiries dealing with the full range of planning and environmental issues and covering a wide range of land uses. Recent inquiries include urban extensions (housing and mixed use), retail proposals, waste recycling proposals, business park proposals and housing in a national park.
Gary provides legal support for development plan examinations and for CIL examinations both for the Plan Making Authority and for objectors.
Advising, drafting and appearing in planning related litigation including injunctions.
Housing and Mixed Use
2017/2018: Call In Inquiry into proposals for up to 1000 houses at Arkhall Farm nr Tamworth going to Inquiry in January 2018 ( for Lichfield DC ).
2017: Residential proposals in Bath, raising issues of WHS, impact on landscape, ecology and scheme design. ( for Appellant ).
2016: Appeal inquiry for 137 houses at Foldgate Lane Ludlow, Shropshire (LPA).
2016: Western Road Leicester, appeal proposals for 279 student flats in 2 blocks (LPA).
2015: Call in Inquiry at Watery Lane, Curborough, nr Lichfield in respect of up to 750 houses and associated development ( For LPA ).
2014: Recovered appeal inquiry in respect of up to 360 houses in Warton for the LPA (Fylde BC ).
2014: Promoted proposals for housing within the National Park at Petersfield at Inquiry ( Appellant).
2013: Appeal Inquiry at Midsomer Norton, Somerset for the LPA
2013: Call in Inquiry at Salford, Bath in the Green Belt.For LPA
2018: Legal support for examination of the Wyre Local Plan heard over 3 weeks in the summer of 2018.
2017: Legal support for EiP of Hartlepool Local Plan which was examined in public over 3 weeks in September-October 2017.
2016: Legal Support for EIP of the Main Modifications to the Stratford Local Plan (Core Strategy) which proceeded to adoption in July 2016.
2016: Legal support for CIL Schedule examination for Stratford.
2015: Represented successful objector to CIL Schedule at CIL Examination in Bournemouth.
2015: Appointed to provide legal support with David Manley QC in respect of the Stratford Local Plan EiP.
2015: Appointed to provide discrete legal support in respect of part of the Gloucester, Cheltenham and Tewkesbury Joint Core Strategy
2013: Leading objections into Wiltshire Core Strategy on behalf of developer consortium Chippenham 2020, based on inadequacy of sustainability appraisal and compliance with SEA Regs.
Sport and recreation
2013: Appeal Inquiry at Barfold Farm , Surrey concerned with the intensification of elite polo use in Green Belt and AONB. For LPA
2011: Call in Inquiry on conjoined appeals for the proposals of London Irish RFC to develop a large training facility in the Green Belt and to redevelop the existing ground in Sunbury for mixed use. For LPA .
2018: Proposals for a sheltered housing scheme in the Branksome Park Conservation Area raising issue of heritage, design and land supply ( for LPA ).
2017: Residential proposals for a site opposed in terms of the impact on the World Heritage City of Bath and quality of design ( for A ).
2016: Appeal hearing for 90 dwellings within the setting of a registered battlefield at Kineton.
2013: Appeal Inq promoting Planning and Listed Building consent for the Whiteladies former cinema (Bristol), change of use to gym together with residential.
2012: Appeal inquiry promoting demolition of house in conservation area in Branksome and it’s replacement with a high quality design by award winning architect.
Minerals and Waste:
2015: Enforcement appeal in respect of waste recycling facility in the Hampshire Countryside (for MWPA )
2012: s78 Appeal for waste recycling facility in Hampshire Countryside.
2011: s78 Appeal for green waste processing in Surrey Green Belt.
2018: Junior to Paul Tucker QC for Appellant : Call In Inquiry into retail proposals by Orbit Investments at Handforth Dean consolidated with proposals by CPG – 4 week inquiry .
2017: Public Inquiry: Junior to Paul Tucker QC in relation to proposals for a foodstore in Somerset ( for A ).
2016: Bicester Gateway, Public inquiry into retail proposals for 2 major retailers at Bicester.
Public law challenges emerging from planning disputes. Recent instructions include resisting judicial review proceedings of LPA decisions not to take enforcement action and grant planning permission in respect of equestrian uses in Oxfordshire, Challenge to a Committees consideration of para 32 NPPF, resisting judicial review of use of Housing Act CPO powers and resisting judicial review of a decision to recommend main modifications to a Local Plan and consideration of the ambit of s113 of PPCA 2004.
2017: Challenge to decision of Secretary of State on interpretation of §118 NPPF and strategic policies of recently adopted LP in context of existence of 5 year land supply. Lichfield DC v SSCLG  EWHC 2242(Admin).
2017: Resisting proceedings for judicial review on behalf of LPA in support of SSCLG. Novel case involving the scope of potential challenge to the presence of statuary ( piers and urns of historic significance ) on the list of Listed Buildings. Reported as Dill v SSCLG  EWHC 2378(Admin).
2017: Resisting application for permission to proceed by way of judicial review of Committee decision to grant permission for Rugby Club raising procedural, ecological and policy issues.
2016: Drafting grounds of resistance for LPA on meaning of affordable housing policy in context of issue on aggregation of proposals. The case was successfully defended by the Secretary of State in New Dawn Homes Ltd v SSCLG  3314.
2016: Advising and drafting Pre- action in a case against the LPA involving procedural failings and misinterpretation of policy.
2015: Resisting judicial review proceedings (x2) of decision not to take enforcement action in respect of equestrian uses and impacts ( Planning Court sitting in Birmingham ).
2014: Judicial review proceedings on behalf of Claimant (led by Paul Tucker QC ) challenging a planning committees consideration of para 32 of NPPF.
2014: Resisting judicial review of decision to proceed with the execution of compulsory purchase of property under Housing Act powers ( for Derby Council - Planning Court sitting in Leeds ).
2014: Resisting judicial review of decision to recommend main modifications to the Lichfield Local Plan involving the release of land from the Green Belt and consideration of the ambit of the statutory ouster under section 113 of PPCA 2004 reported at  EWHC 2440 (Admin).
2013: s288 challenge on behalf of Woking Borough concerning inspector’s misinterpretation of Green Belt policy.
Member of PEBA
Attorney General’s Regional Panel 2002-2015
MA (Oxon) Jurisprudence
Accredited Civil and Commercial Mediator.
Legal 500 2018
‘A highly effective advocate.’
Legal 500 2016
“ An excellent advocate with good interpersonal skills”
Legal 500 2015
"His advice is always concise, practical and solution-orientated”
Legal 500 2014