Toby is ranked as a leading junior by both Chambers UK and the Legal 500. He is predominantly instructed in high value personal injury litigation, however, he has an expanding practice in Clinical Negligence and Inquests and was appointed Junior Counsel to the Crown in 2018. He is often instructed in cases involving complicated issues of medical causation and quantum and has significant experience of acting in cases where fundamental dishonesty is alleged.
Year of Call: 2007
Toby has an expanding clinical negligence practice, predominantly but not exclusively representing Claimants in relation to claims arising out of all areas of medical and dental negligence.
SL v Calderdale & Huddersfield NHS Foundation Trust – Representing the Claimant in relation to a claim arising out of the Defendant’s negligent management of her diabetes, which resulted in the Claimant requiring the surgical application of skin grafts to her leg.
BQ v Dr. B, Dr. G and Gateshead Health NHS Foundation Trust – Representing an elderly Claimant who alleged that an accurate diagnosis of cervical cord compression had been negligently delayed by the Defendants.
CR v Cwn Taf University Local Health Board – Representing the Claimant following a negligent failure to diagnose a scaphoid fracture sustained whilst playing rugby, resulting in the need for surgical intervention.
AP v North Tees & Hartlepool NHS Foundation Trust – Representing an elderly Claimant in relation to a claim arising out of the alleged mismanagement of an infection in his foot, resulting in his leg being amputated below the knee.
SW v Lincolnshire Community Health Services – Representing the Claimant following the allegedly negligent decision to discharge his wife from hospital at a time when she was suffering from suspected cardiac chest pain, following which she tragically died.
Toby has a nationwide personal injury and clinical negligence practice, which often leads to him being instructed to represent interested parties at inquests, in order to provide early strategic advice and assess the merits of any potential claims.
Having practised in criminal law during his first few years at the Bar, Toby is an experienced jury advocate.
In 2018, Toby was appointed Junior Counsel to the Crown, which has resulted in him being instructed to represent interested parties at inquests touching the deaths of individuals owed a duty of care by the state.
Recent instructions have included:
Toby has a nationwide personal injury practice. He represents both Claimants and Defendants in relation to claims arising out of accidents at work, in public places and on the road. His list of clients includes a number of major insurers, NHS Trusts, local authorities and the government, having been appointed Junior Counsel to the Crown in 2018.
The majority of his work is allocated to the multi-track and involves complex arguments in relation to breach of duty, causation and quantum. He regularly appears in high value claims and has acted in a number of claims pleaded in excess of £1 million.
Toby is often instructed soon after an accident has occurred in order to advise pre-issue and/or represent the interested party at any inquest. He drafts pleadings and regularly attends interlocutory hearings, conferences with experts, trials and joint settlement meetings.
JH v Harrogate & District NHS Foundation Trust (County Court at Leeds) – Successfully representing the Defendant NHS Trust in relation to an appeal following a finding at trial that the Claimant, who was employed by the Defendant, had sustained personal injury and loss whilst at work as a result of the Defendant’s negligence. The appeal was allowed and the claim dismissed.
DM v NY (QBD, Newcastle District Registry) – Representing a Claimant, who sustained multiple significant injuries having been knocked off his bicycle by a motor vehicle driven by the Defendant.
CF v Doncaster & Bassetlaw Hospitals NHS Trust (County Court at Sheffield) – Representing the Defendant in relation to a claim arising out of an accident at work, as a result of which the Claimant alleges that she went on to develop Chronic Regional Pain Syndrome.
Inquest touching the death of DW (South Yorkshire Coroner’s Court - HM Senior Coroner C.O. Dorries OBE) – Representing the organisers of the Tour de Yorkshire Sportive at the inquest touching the death of a participant who was killed when the bicycle he was riding came into contact with a coach which was exiting a junction.
AJ v Yorkshire Ambulance Service NHS Trust (County Court at Leeds) – Successfully representing the Defendant NHS Trust in relation to an appeal following a finding at trial that the Claimant, who was a Paramedic, had sustained personal injury and loss whilst at work as a result of the Defendant’s negligence. The appeal was allowed and the claim dismissed.
BM (by her litigation friend JM) v Orchard Care Homes (QBD, Leeds District Registry) – Representing the Defendant care home in relation to a claim arising out of an elderly lady falling from a first floor window and sustaining serious injury.
JM v WN Contractors (County Court at Manchester) – Representing the Defendant in relation to a claim arising out of an accident on a building site, resulting in the Claimant sustaining a significant knee injury when he tripped whilst carrying a manhole cover.
L v ME Ltd (County Court at Leeds) – Representing the Defendant in relation to a claim arising out of an accident at work, in circumstances where the Claimant fell from height whilst installing an air conditioning unit, sustaining a brain injury.
NX (a child) v SS & EW (QBD, Birmingham District Registry) – Representing the Defendant in relation to a claim involving a pedestrian being struck by a car, allegedly giving rise to a significant brain injury.
M v D & Aviva Insurance (County Court at Bradford) – Representing the Defendant in relation to a claim by a taxi driver who suffered a traumatic brain injury in a road traffic collision.
Personal Injury Bar Association
North Eastern Circuit
Junior Counsel to the Crown (2018-2023)
Secretary to the Henry Scott Fund
Golf Junior, North Eastern Circuit
Degree: University of Leeds, LLB (Hons)
BVC: BPP Leeds, Outstanding
Year of Call: 2007 (Lincoln’s Inn)
Awards: Buchanan Prize and Wolfson Scholarship
Legal 500 2020
"Adds value to any instruction due to his in depth knowledge and extensive preparation."
Chambers UK 2020
"A safe pair of hands."
"Predominantly represents defendants in insurance fraud cases. He is instructed in both multi-track and fast-track claims and is recognised as a rising star in the personal injury field. His clients include several insurance companies, local authorities, NHS trusts and the MIB. He increasingly acts for claimants who have sustained life-changing injuries."
Chambers UK 2019
“Recognised as a rising star in the personal injury field”
“He has very good attention to detail”
“A very reasonable and sensible advocate”
Legal 500 2019
“Highly experienced in cases involving life-changing injuries”
Chambers UK 2018
“Recognised as a rising star in the personal injury field”
Legal 500 2018
“Known for acting in claims involving life-changing injuries”
Legal 500 2017
“He has an excellent ability to analyse the details, set a strategy, communicate to the client and present in court”
Legal 500 2016
“Never fails to impress insurer and lay clients alike; definitely one to watch”
36 Young Street, Manchester, M3 3FT
DX: 718188 MCH 3
Direct Dial: 0161 832 9082
5 Park Square, Leeds, LS1 2NE
DX: 713113 LEEDS PARK SQ
Direct Dial: 0113 242 1123
Embassy House, 60 Church Street,
Birmingham, B3 2DJ
DX: 13023 BIRMINGHAM
Direct Dial: 0121 200 3570
© Copyright 2019 Kings Chambers. All rights reserved.